Most confusion about Turnitin starts here. A Similarity Report and an AI writing score are produced by separate machinery and mean separate things, and students routinely read one as though it were the other.
The similarity score is the old one. It matches your text against Turnitin's repository of published work, web pages and previously submitted papers, and reports how much overlaps. A high number means your words appear somewhere else. It is a matching problem, and it is largely a solved one.
The AI writing indicator compares your text against nothing. It reads the prose and estimates how machine-typical the writing is, using signals like perplexity — how predictable each next word is — and burstiness, the variation in sentence length and structure. Human writing tends to be uneven. Model writing tends toward smooth and medium-everything.
The practical consequence: you can score 0% similarity and still be flagged for AI, or score 40% similarity on a properly quoted literature review and have no AI flag at all. The two numbers do not constrain each other. How detectors work covers the mechanism in full.